|
Post by Stripes on Mar 10, 2010 1:20:55 GMT
the rules are the same as Doctor v. Doctor, except you can take THREE POINTS off instead of two (-3) it's just such a big sheet...
You can still only add one point a day.
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 10 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 10 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 11 (+1) Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 10 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 10 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 10 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 10 Polly 7 (-3) Romana I 10 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 10 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 10 Tegan Jovanka 10 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 10 Vislor Turlough 10 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by clocketpatch on Mar 10, 2010 1:42:34 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 10 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 7 (-3) NOT A REAL COMPANION *growls* Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 (+1) Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 10 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 10 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 10 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 10 Polly 7 Romana I 10 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 10 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 10 Tegan Jovanka 10 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 10 Vislor Turlough 10 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by Starflower on Mar 10, 2010 1:44:42 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 10 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 7 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 10 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 11(+1) Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 10 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 7(-3) Polly 7 Romana I 10 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 10 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 10 Tegan Jovanka 10 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 10 Vislor Turlough 10 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by primsong on Mar 10, 2010 2:25:25 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 10 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 7 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 10 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 12 (+1) Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 (-3) Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 7 Polly 7 Romana I 10 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 10 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 10 Tegan Jovanka 10 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 10 Vislor Turlough 10 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
Stacey
UNIT Red Shirt
Posts: 146
|
Post by Stacey on Mar 10, 2010 10:05:35 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 10 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 7 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 10 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 12 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 7 Polly 7 Romana I 10 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 10 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 (-3) Tegan Jovanka 10 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11(+1) Vislor Turlough 10 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by merrythemad on Mar 10, 2010 11:56:46 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 (-3) Adric 10 Astrid Peth 8 (+1) Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 10 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 12 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 7 Polly 7 Romana I 10 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 10 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 10 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 10 Zoe Heriot 10
while I can see Astrid needs to go; I cannot see it whilst Adam "but I wanna play the lotto" Mitchell is about.
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 10, 2010 16:07:31 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 8 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 10 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 12 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 7 Polly 7 Romana I 11 (+1) Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 7 (-3) Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 10 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 10 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by Stripes on Mar 10, 2010 16:51:48 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 5 (-3) I AGREE WITH CLOCKET! Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 11 (+1) Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 12 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 7 Polly 7 Romana I 11 (+1) Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 7 (-3) Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 10 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 10 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by Abbyromana on Mar 10, 2010 17:44:58 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 5 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 11 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 12 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 7 Polly 7 Romana I 11 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 7 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 7 (-3) Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 (+1) Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by Starflower on Mar 10, 2010 21:28:46 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 5 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 11 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13(+1) Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 10 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4(-3) Polly 7 Romana I 11 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 7 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 7 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by primsong on Mar 10, 2010 21:58:18 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 5 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 11 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 11 (+1) Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4 Polly 7 Romana I 11 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 4 (-3) Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 7 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by clocketpatch on Mar 10, 2010 23:49:43 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adric 10 Astrid Peth 2 (-3) just punt her another good one... Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 11 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 11 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4 Polly 7 Romana I 11 Romana II 10 Rose Tyler 5 (+1) I honestly don't know why I just did that Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 7 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 11, 2010 0:03:05 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adric 7 (-3) Astrid Peth 2 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 11 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 11 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4 Polly 7 Romana I 11 Romana II 11 (+1) Rose Tyler 5 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 7 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by librarylover on Mar 11, 2010 0:18:00 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adelaide Brooke Adric 7 Astrid Peth -1 (-3) Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 12 (+1) Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 11 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4 Polly 7 Romana I 11 Romana II 11 Rose Tyler 5 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 7 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
Although I agree with Merry's comment about Adam, I was in a homicidal mood. Plus I believe that VOTD would have been slightly better if a better actress had played her!
|
|
Stacey
UNIT Red Shirt
Posts: 146
|
Post by Stacey on Mar 11, 2010 11:32:57 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 7 Adelaide Brooke Adric 7 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 12 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 11 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4 Polly 8 (+1) Romana I 11 Romana II 11 Rose Tyler 2 (-3) Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 7 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by merrythemad on Mar 11, 2010 13:22:17 GMT
Ace 10 Adam Mitchell 4 (-3) Adelaide Brooke Adric 7 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 12 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 11 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4 Polly 8 Romana I 11 Romana II 11 Rose Tyler 2 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 8 (+1) Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
Coupla things folks. 1. Adelaide has no points which I assume means she has killed herself to spare the future.
2. I think you lot are being unfair to Rose, yes Ten made her her wibble, but there are companions that are waaaaay worse who haven't even been hit! To gun for her is still making her special you realise.... and I assume the point of Rose-bashing is to render her "unspecial"
|
|
|
Post by Abbyromana on Mar 11, 2010 18:31:11 GMT
Coupla things folks. 1. Adelaide has no points which I assume means she has killed herself to spare the future. 2. I think you lot are being unfair to Rose, yes Ten made her her wibble, but there are companions that are waaaaay worse who haven't even been hit! To gun for her is still making her special you realise.... and I assume the point of Rose-bashing is to render her "unspecial" First, I think someone added Adelaide, because she wasn't on the original list. I'm going to remove her, since it isn't fair to add someone part way through. Second, I like Rose (I never get why people seem to target her either, Merry), but I have others I like more so I'm just focusing on them first... still here' s me trying to help keep her alive. Adam Mitchell 4 Adric 7 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 12 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 11 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4 Polly 8 Romana I 11 Romana II 11 Rose Tyler 3 (+1) Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 5 (-3) Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 11, 2010 19:24:16 GMT
Coupla things folks. 1. Adelaide has no points which I assume means she has killed herself to spare the future. 2. I think you lot are being unfair to Rose, yes Ten made her her wibble, but there are companions that are waaaaay worse who haven't even been hit! To gun for her is still making her special you realise.... and I assume the point of Rose-bashing is to render her "unspecial" I'm not bashing. I'm just taking away points from my least favourite and adding to my favourite. Nothing personal. Also, there being way worse companions is a matter of personal opinion. Not saying I agree or disagree, just sayin'.;D
|
|
|
Post by merrythemad on Mar 11, 2010 22:18:27 GMT
lol, fair point, Maggie but, honestly, I bet not one person thinks Adam Mitchell is better than any companion, even if he wouldn't come up int heir worst list.
|
|
|
Post by jjpor on Mar 11, 2010 22:53:09 GMT
Couldn't we just count Season 1 Rose and Season 2 Rose as two separate companions? Then everybody's happy (apart from the people who actually liked S2...I don't know, talk about all of the people all of the time...) ;D
I'm not sure I'd even count Adam as a companion - more of a character-of-the-week who happened to get carried over to the next story... But then, I guess that would also cover Sara Kingdom and Katarina, the other two members of the Triad of Companions Who Died For Real... And if we're counting the Brig and Benton (although I for one think the whole UNIT family should count as companions...actually, where's Yatesy on the list??!)... Ah, this whole companion/not a companion issue hurts my brain...
Having said all of that:
Ace 11 (+1) Adam Mitchell 1 (-3) Adric 7 Barbara Wright 10 Ben Jackson 10 Benton 12 Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart 10 Charlotte Pollard 10 Dodo Chaplet 10 Donna Noble 12 Erimen 10 Evelyn Smythe 10 Grace Holloway 10 Harry Sullivan 10 Hex 10 Ian Chesterton 13 Jackie Tyler 10 Jamie McCrimmon 10 Jo Grant 11 Jack Harkness 10 K-9 10 Kamelion 7 Katarina 10 Lady Christina de Souza 10 Leela 10 Liz Shaw 10 Lucy Miller 10 Martha Jones 10 Melanie Bush 10 Mickey Smith 10 Nyssa 10 Peri Brown 4 Polly 8 Romana I 11 Romana II 11 Rose Tyler 3 Sara Kingdom 10 Sarah Jane Smith 10 Steven Taylor 10 Susan Foreman 7 Tegan Jovanka 5 Steven Taylor 10 Vicki 10 Victoria Waterfield 11 Vislor Turlough 11 Zoe Heriot 10
|
|