|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 7, 2013 22:04:52 GMT
Since we're all about celebrating 50 Years of Who these days, I thought it might be fun to rate the first full serials/episodes (+1 movie) of all the Doctors. I'm saying first full episode because we're not counting the first two minutes of screen-time most of them get in their predecessor's final episode (for one thing, not all of them get that). I realise that this one might not be entirely fair given that Two's first serial is entirely missing, but... the Universe ain't fair!
Anyway, you know the rules:
One - An Unearthly Child (12) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (12) Four - Robot (12) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (12) Seven - Time and the Rani (12) Eight - The Movie (12) Nine - Rose (12) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (12) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (12)
ETA: Changed ''episode'' to ''story'' because it so neatly covers everything.
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 8, 2013 15:48:47 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (12) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (12) Four - Robot (13) +1 Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (12) Seven - Time and the Rani (12) Eight - The Movie (10) -2 Nine - Rose (12) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (12) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (12)
|
|
|
Post by jjpor on Mar 8, 2013 21:38:15 GMT
Nice one One - An Unearthly Child (13) +1 Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (12) Four - Robot (13) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (10) -2 Seven - Time and the Rani (12) Eight - The Movie (10) Nine - Rose (12) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (12) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (12)
|
|
|
Post by aquabluejay on Mar 8, 2013 23:49:32 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (13) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (12) Four - Robot (13) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (8)-2 Seven - Time and the Rani (12) Eight - The Movie (10) Nine - Rose (12) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (13)+1 Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (12)
|
|
|
Post by jjpor on Mar 9, 2013 0:33:41 GMT
The Twin Dilemma, sad to say, really deserves a good kicking...
|
|
|
Post by IMForeman on Mar 9, 2013 0:41:35 GMT
I like this idea!
One - An Unearthly Child (13) Two - Power of the Daleks (12)+1 Three - Spearhead From Space (12) Four - Robot (13) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (8) Seven - Time and the Rani (10) -2 Eight - The Movie (10) Nine - Rose (12) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (13) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (12)
I think Power of the Daleks is kind of an extraordinary first story if you consider the fact that up until then, the Doctor was played by just one actor.
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 9, 2013 0:44:28 GMT
Sure was, IMF. One - An Unearthly Child (13) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (12) Four - Robot (14) +1 Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (6) -2 Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (10) Nine - Rose (12) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (13) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (12)
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 10, 2013 0:45:08 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (14) +1 Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (12) Four - Robot (14) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (6) Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (8) -2 Nine - Rose (12) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (13) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (12)
|
|
|
Post by starpanda on Mar 10, 2013 1:22:10 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (14) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) +1 Four - Robot (14) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (6) Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (8) Nine - Rose (10) -2 Ten - The Christmas Invasion (13) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (12) Because it was a total rip-off.
|
|
|
Post by IMForeman on Mar 10, 2013 1:55:11 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (14) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (14) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (4) -2 Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (8) Nine - Rose (10) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (13) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (13) +1
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 11, 2013 0:14:08 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (14) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (15) +1 Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (4) Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (6) -2 Nine - Rose (10) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (13) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (13)
|
|
|
Post by aquabluejay on Mar 11, 2013 22:11:17 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (14) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (15) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (2) -2 Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (6) Nine - Rose (10) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (14+1 Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (13)
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 12, 2013 0:11:06 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (15) +1 Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (15) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (2) Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (4) -2 Nine - Rose (10) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (14) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (13)
|
|
kirkg
Auton Daisy
"Hello, Sweetie!"
Posts: 442
|
Post by kirkg on Mar 12, 2013 4:17:23 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (15) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (15) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (2) Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (2) -2 Nine - Rose (11) +1 Ten - The Christmas Invasion (14) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (13)
If you don't mind, I think I'll vote for The Twin Dilemma as one of the two shows we watch from SIX, just so that I can enjoy the awful goodness and judge for myself before it fades into obscurity, eh?
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 13, 2013 0:53:16 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (16) +1 Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (15) Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (2) Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Eight - The Movie (0) -2 Nine - Rose (11) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (14) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (13) Sorry, Mr McGann. It's not you.
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 14, 2013 0:18:56 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (16) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (16) +1 Five - Castrovalva (12) Six - The Twin Dilemma (0) -2 Seven - Time and the Rani (10) Nine - Rose (11) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (14) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (13) Two kills in a row. *rubs hands* Sorry, I couldn't use That Scene. Way too disturbing.
|
|
|
Post by jjpor on Mar 14, 2013 20:58:21 GMT
It probably seemed like a good idea to them at the time. The dolts.
One - An Unearthly Child (16) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (16) Five - Castrovalva (12) Seven - Time and the Rani (8) -2 Nine - Rose (11) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (14) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (14) +1
Sorry Seven - I love you, but your first might actually be your worst story. As inherently amusing as the Rani is. Trouble is, I don't actually dislike any of the remaining stories. The ones I really have a problem with are already gone...
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 15, 2013 0:15:55 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (17) +1 Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (16) Five - Castrovalva (12) Seven - Time and the Rani (6) -2 Nine - Rose (11) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (14) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (14)
|
|
|
Post by Maggadin on Mar 16, 2013 0:22:34 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (17) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (13) Four - Robot (17) +1 Five - Castrovalva (12) Seven - Time and the Rani (4) (-2) Nine - Rose (11) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (14) Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (14)
|
|
|
Post by primsong on Mar 16, 2013 4:23:15 GMT
One - An Unearthly Child (17) Two - Power of the Daleks (12) Three - Spearhead From Space (14) +1 Four - Robot (17) Five - Castrovalva (12) Seven - Time and the Rani (4) Nine - Rose (11) Ten - The Christmas Invasion (12) -2 Eleven - The Eleventh Hour (14)
|
|